How to Host a Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Star Wars Strangulation

From: $25.00 USD

Hippie Homicide 1960s

From: $25.00 USD

Masquerade Ball Brutality

From: $25.00 USD

View All Games

Introduction

Why a murder mystery makes the perfect dinner party?

A murder mystery adds something extra to an ordinary dinner party by giving your guests an entertaining activity to enjoy together. Instead of simply sitting around the table and making conversation, everyone becomes part of the mystery, with characters to play, secrets to uncover and a murder to solve. It creates plenty of laughs, gets guests talking and gives everyone a reason to interact, making your dinner party more memorable and enjoyable.

Who is this guide for?

• Adults hosting a dinner party
• Friends organizing a dinner party
• Family celebrations
• Couples hosting friends
• Anyone looking for an alternative to a traditional dinner party

What is a Murder Mystery Dinner Party?

A murder mystery dinner party combines a meal with an interactive mystery where guests become characters, uncover clues, question suspects and work to solve the crime. Guests can expect plenty of interaction, conversation, secrets and surprises throughout the game, but no acting experience is required. How involved guests become is up to them, making the format suitable for people who enjoy performing as well as those who prefer to simply play their character and solve the mystery. Most murder mystery dinner parties last several hours, depending on the game, number of guests and how you plan your meal.

Why Choose a Murder Mystery Dinner Party?

• Give everyone something to do
• Get guests talking
• Break the ice
• Make your dinner party memorable
• Combine dinner and entertainment
• Create plenty of laughs and surprises
• Perfect for guests who do not know each other
• Suitable for small and large dinner parties

Understanding Your Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Although every murder mystery has its own story, characters and surprises, the basic structure is similar. Guests enjoy food and drinks while taking part in the mystery, receiving character information, discovering clues, questioning one another and gradually uncovering the secrets, motives and suspicious behavior surrounding the crime. The meal can be planned around the game, with courses, drinks and socialising helping to create natural breaks in the investigation. As the evening develops, new information and unexpected twists keep everyone guessing until the final accusation and big reveal.

• Guests arrive, are welcomed and enjoy drinks and appetisers.
• Guests receive their character information and learn about their role in the story.
• The host or presenter delivers an opening storyline and sets the scene.
• A terrible and tragic murder occurs.
• The host or presenter explains how the game works.
• The mystery and investigation begin.
• Guests enjoy the first course or meal while mingling, questioning one another and investigating the crime.
• Players reveal clues and exchange information.
• Further courses, drinks and refreshments can be served throughout the evening.
• Evidence, secrets and motives gradually emerge.
• Guests work together, or compete with one another, to identify suspects and solve the mystery.
• Additional clues and plot twists are introduced throughout the game.
• Players discuss their theories and try to eliminate suspects.
• Even if someone thinks they know who the murderer is early, the investigation continues as new information may change everything.
• Guests make their final accusations.
• The murderer is revealed and the mystery is explained.
• Prizes or awards can be presented.
• Guests enjoy dessert, celebrate, take photos and continue socialising.

Intravenous Investigation

From: $25.00 USD

Soap Opera Slaughter

From: $25.00 USD

Facebook Fatality

From: $25.00 USD

View All Games

Planning Your Murder Mystery Dinner Party

Choosing the date and time

Choose a date and time that gives your guests plenty of notice and allows enough time for both the meal and the murder mystery. An evening dinner is a popular choice, but a lunch or afternoon event can work just as well.

Deciding how many guests to invite

Decide how many people you want to invite before choosing your game, as different murder mysteries are designed for different group sizes. Most murder mystery dinners are for small groups but you can host bigger groups too.

Setting a realistic budget

Work out your budget before making arrangements and consider the cost of the murder mystery game, food, drinks, venue, decorations and costumes. Hosting at home can keep costs down, while a commercial venue may add extra expenses.

Planning the evening

Plan how you want the evening to flow from the moment guests arrive until the final reveal. Allow time for guests to socialise, enjoy drinks and food, take part in the mystery and relax between different stages of the game.

Creating a dinner party timeline

Use the run sheet that comes with your game to stay on track with time.

Allowing enough time for the game

Do not try to rush the mystery just to fit it around dinner. Allow enough time for guests to read their character information, question one another, discover clues and develop their theories before making their final accusations. 2 to 3 hours is about right.

Planning food around the mystery

Think about how your food will work alongside the game. Finger food and buffets allow guests to keep mingling and investigating, while a sit-down dinner may work better with the mystery divided into stages between courses.

Choosing the Perfect Venue

Hosting a murder mystery dinner at home

Hosting at home gives you complete control over the food, drinks, decorations, music and timing. It is often the simplest and most flexible option, especially if you have a suitable space where guests can comfortably eat, mingle and take part in the mystery.

Hosting at a friend or family member's house

If your home is not suitable, consider hosting at a friend or family member's house. This can give you more space while still providing the relaxed atmosphere of a private home. Make sure there is enough room for guests to move around and interact during the game.

Restaurants and private dining rooms

A private dining room can combine the murder mystery with a professionally prepared meal, making it a convenient option if you do not want to cook. Check that the space allows guests to interact freely and that the restaurant is comfortable with the timing and format of the game.

Function rooms and commercial venues

Function rooms, hotels and other commercial venues can be a good option for larger dinner parties. If you have a small group sitting around a single dining table, you can play a murder mystery in almost any suitable private space. As your guest numbers increase, however, you will want a venue that gives guests more room to move around and interact during the mystery.

What makes a good murder mystery dinner venue

For smaller groups there are no limits. Host your party anywhere. For larger dinner parties, look for a private venue where guests can enjoy their meal while still having plenty of space to mingle, question one another and investigate the mystery. The dining area should be comfortable, but avoid arranging the room so that everyone is stuck sitting at the table for the entire game. A venue that naturally suits your theme can also make the evening more immersive. A 1920s murder mystery dinner, for example, can feel even more special in an elegant Art Deco room, historic hotel or venue with a vintage atmosphere.

Privacy becomes increasingly important as your group gets larger. Ideally, your group should have its own private room where everyone can hear the conversation and the host or presenter can control the atmosphere without competing with other patrons, conversations or music.

For larger dinner parties, look for:

• A completely private room used only by your group.
• Enough open space for guests to move around and mingle.
• Tables and furniture that do not restrict movement.
• Music and noise levels that you can control.
• A venue that naturally complements the theme of your murder mystery.
• A layout that allows guests to move away from the dining table during the investigation.
• Good acoustics so guests can hear the host, presenter and one another.

Try to avoid venues where your group shares the space with other patrons. This becomes particularly important with larger groups, as a murder mystery can become lively and interactive. Background noise, interruptions and nearby conversations can make it difficult for guests to hear clues and follow the story.

For larger groups, venues to avoid include:

• One section of a busy restaurant rather than a completely private room.
• Rooms shared with other groups or patrons.
• Spaces separated only by a curtain or temporary partition.
• Venues with significant noise from nearby guests.
• Rooms with music playing next door or piped music that you cannot control.
• Rooms packed with tables and furniture, leaving little space to move around.
• Venues with large amounts of unmovable furniture.

Murder mystery dinners on trains or boats can create a fantastic themed experience, but they can be more difficult to manage with larger groups. Limited space, fixed seating and the challenge of moving guests around can make the investigation more complicated, so these venues are generally better suited to experienced hosts and presenters.

Inviting Your Guests

When to send dinner party invitations

Send your invitations several weeks before the dinner party so guests have plenty of time to keep the date free, RSVP and make any plans they need to attend. Larger dinner parties may benefit from giving guests even more notice.

Digital vs printed invitations

Digital invitations are a simple and convenient option for most dinner parties, while printed invitations can add an extra touch for a themed event. Choose whichever suits the style of your party and your guests.

What information to include

Include the date, time, venue, RSVP details and any important information guests need to know. Let them know that it is a murder mystery dinner party, but keep the details of the actual mystery secret.

Explaining the murder mystery theme

Tell guests the theme of the murder mystery so they know what to expect and can plan their costumes. You can tell them whether the game has a 1920s, Hollywood, pirate or other theme without revealing the murder, characters, clues or mystery itself.

Sending character information before the party

We do not recommend sending character information before the party. Characters can be allocated on the night, which makes cancellations and last minute guests much easier to manage. It also means you can keep the mystery and character details secret until the game begins.

Explaining costume expectations

Let guests know whether costumes are encouraged and give them some simple ideas based on the theme. Make it clear that dressing up is optional, as guests should still be able to enjoy the murder mystery without wearing a costume.

Collecting RSVPs

Ask guests to RSVP by a specific date so you know how many people will be attending. This helps you choose the right game, plan the seating and organize enough food and drinks for everyone.

Handling guests who cancel

Do not worry too much about cancellations, particularly if characters are allocated on the night. Most murder mystery games have flexible player numbers, making it easier to adjust the character allocation when someone can no longer attend.

Building excitement before the dinner party

Build anticipation by reminding guests about the theme, encouraging costumes and sharing a few details about the evening without revealing the mystery. Keep the murder, characters, clues and storyline secret so guests arrive curious and ready to investigate.

Choosing the Right Murder Mystery Game

Choosing a game to suit your guests

Choose a game based on your guests, the size of your dinner party and the type of evening you want to create. You can also choose a favorite era or theme, with popular options including the 1920s, 1960s and 1980s.

Downloadable vs boxed games

Downloadable games offer instant access and are a convenient option when you are planning your dinner party at short notice. Boxed games arrive ready for your party with the physical materials you need to run the mystery.

Games for small dinner parties

For smaller dinner parties, games are available for 4 to 6 and 7 to 10 people. These smaller groups can comfortably play around a single dining table, making them ideal for a more intimate dinner party.

Games for medium-sized groups

For medium-sized dinner parties, games are available for 9 to 15 and 16 to 30 people. With larger groups, guests can move around and mingle more during the investigation while still enjoying the dinner together.

Games for large dinner parties

For larger dinner parties, games are available for 31 to 60 and 61 to 120 people. These groups work best in a larger private venue with enough space for guests to move around, interact and investigate the mystery.

Games with flexible player numbers

All our games have flexible player numbers, making it easy to accommodate last minute cancellations or additional guests. This is particularly useful when planning a dinner party, as your final guest numbers can sometimes change.

Choosing a Murder Mystery Theme

• 1920s, Great Gatsby, Gangsters and Mafia themes
• Hollywood and movie star themes
• 80s themed murder mysteries
• Hippie and 60s themes
• Masquerade parties
• Pirate and cruise themes
• Haunted and Halloween-style mysteries
• Choose a theme that suits your guests and gives you plenty of opportunities for themed food, drinks, costumes and decorations.

Planning the Dinner

Planning food around the murder mystery

How you plan the food depends largely on the size of your dinner party. With a small group, you can be much more flexible and enjoy your meal whenever it suits the evening. With larger groups, it is usually easier to play the murder mystery either before dinner or after everyone has finished eating.

Finger food and cocktail parties

Finger food and cocktail-style dinners work particularly well for smaller groups because guests can eat, drink and mingle while taking part in the mystery. They also make it easy for guests to move around and interact with one another.

Buffet dinners

A buffet gives guests flexibility and can work well alongside a murder mystery. For smaller groups, guests can serve themselves throughout the evening, while larger groups may find it easier to have dinner before or after the game.

Sit-down dinners

A sit-down dinner is ideal for smaller groups where everyone can comfortably sit around one table and take part in the mystery. For larger groups, consider serving the meal before the game or holding the mystery after dinner so guests are not trying to eat while investigating the crime.

When to serve each course

There is no single right way to structure the meal. Small groups can serve appetisers, main courses and dessert around the game as they prefer. With larger groups, serving the complete meal before or after the mystery can make the evening easier to manage.

Drinks and refreshments

Have drinks and refreshments available throughout the evening, particularly when guests are arriving and socialising. Make sure guests have easy access to water and other non-alcoholic options as well.

Themed food and drinks

Themed food and drinks can add another layer of fun to your murder mystery dinner. Match your menu to the setting of the game, whether that means cocktails for a 1920s mystery, tropical drinks for a cruise theme or retro treats for an 80s murder mystery.

Dietary requirements

Ask your guests about dietary requirements when they RSVP so you can plan the menu accordingly. It is much easier to organize suitable alternatives in advance than trying to accommodate special requirements on the night.

Costumes and Dressing Up

Should costumes be encouraged?

Costumes are not essential, but they can make a murder mystery dinner even more fun and help guests get into the spirit of the theme. Encourage guests to dress up without making it feel like an obligation.

Making costumes easy for guests

Keep costumes simple and give guests plenty of notice about the theme. Many guests can create a costume from clothes and accessories they already own, so there is usually no need to spend a lot of money.

Simple costume ideas

Think about easy accessories that quickly establish the theme, such as hats, feather boas, sunglasses, jewellery or jackets. A few simple pieces can be enough to transform an ordinary outfit into a fun murder mystery costume.

Helping guests who do not want to dress up

Not everyone enjoys dressing up, so make it clear that costumes are optional. Guests who prefer not to dress up can still take part fully in the murder mystery and have just as much fun solving the crime.

Costume prizes and awards

Consider presenting a prize or award for the best dressed guest at the end of the evening. It is a simple way to encourage costumes and gives everyone another reason to get creative with the theme.

Should You Run It Yourself or Hire a Presenter?

Benefits of running your own dinner party

Running your own murder mystery dinner party is the most affordable and flexible option. You can host the game almost anywhere and at any time that suits you, without needing to arrange a professional entertainer. Our games include everything you need to run the mystery, making it easy for a friend or family member to take on the role of host. It is a great choice if you want to keep costs down while still creating an exciting and memorable dinner party.

Benefits of hiring a professional presenter

A professional presenter brings experience and energy to your dinner party. They know how to explain the game, keep the mystery moving, encourage guests to participate and manage any unexpected situations. Hiring a presenter also means you can relax and enjoy the dinner instead of worrying about the schedule, clues and instructions. This can be particularly useful for larger dinner parties or if you simply want someone else to take care of running the event.

Can the host also play the game?

The host can also play the game, but if possible, it is usually better to have someone else take on the hosting role. The host may need to give instructions, manage clues and keep the game moving. Having someone else run the mystery allows the host to relax, enjoy the dinner and become fully involved in the game alongside the other guests.

Choosing a friend to host

If you decide not to hire a professional presenter, ask a friend or family member to host the mystery. Choose someone who is comfortable speaking to the group, following instructions and keeping the evening moving. This allows everyone else to concentrate on enjoying the dinner and solving the murder.

To hire a professional presenter, you can use our murder mystery presenter search to find presenters in your country.

Murder Mystery Dinner Party Tips

• Prepare the room before guests arrive
• Give guests time to socialise
• Do not reveal the mystery too early
• Keep the dinner and mystery flowing
• Encourage participation without forcing anyone
• Keep the energy high
• Take plenty of photos
• Have prizes ready
• Plan what happens after the mystery

Ready to Host Your Murder Mystery Dinner Party?

Poker Poisoning

From: $25.00 USD

Disney Disaster

From: $25.00 USD

Haunted Horrors

From: $25.00 USD

View All Games

Locations we provide murder mystery birthday parties:

• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Australia
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party New Zealand
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party United States
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Canada
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party United Kingdom
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Netherlands
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party South Africa
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Singapore
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Ireland
• Murder Mystery Dinner Party Germany