Murder Mystery Dinner Party New York
[Updated: September 2026]
Bring together good food, great company and a crime that needs solving. Our murder mystery games transform dinner parties and restaurant gatherings in New York into interactive dining experiences where guests can enjoy every course while exchanging clues, discussing suspects and piecing together the evidence to discover the culprit.
Best murder mystery party game kits for a dinner party in New York
Medieval Madness
Tokyo Terror
Poker Poisoning
View All Games
Find your perfect game!
Format:
Dinner Party Quick Guide
- Boxed murder mystery games delivered straight to your dinner location in New York
- Instant downloads
- Small or large groups
- Run at home or in any venue
- Most are self hosted, but you will need a host for large events
- See our full list of murder mystery games here
- Small group "Dinner Edition" games 4 to 6, 7 to 10 people
- Medium group "Premium Edition" games 9 to 15, 16 to 30 people
- Large group "Premium Edition" games 31 to 60, 61 to 120, 121 to 300, 301 to 600 people
- Any mix of male, female or gender neutral players
What is a murder mystery dinner?
Serve up dinner with a side of suspense and you have a murder mystery dinner. Guests enjoy a delicious meal while playing characters involved in an entertaining fictional crime. As each course is served, they can question suspects, compare clues and share theories, turning the dining table into the center of the investigation.
Google Review
★★★★★ To Die For! Been playing Murder with these games for years and years now... always killer fun.
Murder mystery games designed for dinner parties
Our murder mystery games take dinner entertainment to another level by making every guest part of the story. While enjoying delicious food, drinks and dessert, participants can question characters, uncover clues and develop their own theories. It is a wonderfully interactive way to enjoy a meal without sacrificing the relaxed pleasure of dining together.
- Your dinner becomes an interactive mystery where every guest has a role in the story.
- Our presenter guide helps you serve up a fantastic mystery dinner with ease.
- There is no need for acting skills or previous murder mystery experience.
- Changes to your dinner guest list can be handled easily.
- Everyone can enjoy the meal while investigating clues and hunting for the murderer.
Popular dinner party activities in New York
Small and Large Group Dinners
Planning a memorable group dinner in New York? Make the menu more exciting by adding a murder mystery. Small dinner parties can enjoy a close and engaging investigation, while larger groups can create an atmosphere buzzing with clues and accusations. Combine delicious food, restaurant dining and entertainment for an unforgettable night.
- Make your next dinner wonderfully unpredictable
- Enjoy fantastic food with small groups or larger gatherings
- Turn large group restaurant dining into an interactive mystery
- Keep guests entertained from appetiser to dessert
- Create a memorable feast filled with mystery
East of New York
Turn your restaurant tables into a thrilling crime scene. Venues east of New York can offer their own murder mystery dinners, combining delicious dining with clues, characters and an entertaining investigation that unfolds throughout the meal.
- Enjoy a delicious mystery dinner east of New York
- Experience restaurants with a wonderfully mysterious twist
- Combine great food with fascinating crime solving
- Enjoy dinner, drinks and plenty of intrigue
- Make your next dining experience unforgettable
Corporate Work Dinner
After a busy conference in New York, give your guests something far more exciting than an ordinary restaurant dinner. A murder mystery dinner combines delicious food, refreshing drinks and interactive entertainment in one memorable corporate event. Settle around the table, enjoy each course and watch the investigation unfold throughout the evening.
- Add excitement to conference and corporate dinners
- Combine delicious food with interactive mystery entertainment
- Give business guests something memorable between courses
- Enjoy restaurant dining with a thrilling twist
- Encourage lively conversation over dinner and drinks
North of New York
Serve up dinner with a side of suspense. Restaurants and dining venues north of New York can offer their own murder mystery dinners, creating an entertaining night where guests can enjoy delicious food, drinks and conversation while solving a fictional crime.
- Find a delicious murder mystery dinner near you
- Enjoy an unforgettable evening at a restaurant
- Dine, drink and investigate throughout the evening
- Enjoy fantastic food alongside an entertaining murder mystery
- Make your next dinner reservation more exciting
Murder Mystery Dinner at Home
Create your own unforgettable murder mystery restaurant experience at home in New York. With a delicious menu, beautifully set table and plenty of suspicious characters, your dining room becomes the perfect setting for an evening of intrigue. Enjoy every course while the investigation gradually reveals the killer.
- Transform your dining room into a mystery restaurant
- Enjoy delicious food throughout an exciting investigation
- Keep guests entertained between every dinner course
- Combine great cooking with fascinating characters
- Create an unforgettable evening around the table
South of New York
Give your restaurant calendar a deliciously dangerous addition. Restaurants and venues south of New York can host their own murder mystery dinners, allowing guests to enjoy your menu while mingling, investigating clues and discovering who is hiding the deadly secret.
- Book an entertaining murder mystery dinner nearby
- Discover delicious restaurant dining with intrigue
- Enjoy a meal while solving a murder
- Turn your dinner table into a crime scene
- Experience an unforgettable mystery dinner south of New York
West of New York
Turn an evening meal into a delicious dining adventure. Restaurants and venues west of New York can offer their own murder mystery dinners, allowing guests to enjoy fantastic food while becoming part of an entertaining interactive mystery.
- Book an exciting murder mystery dinner west of New York
- Enjoy fantastic restaurant food and entertainment
- Discover dining venues with interactive murder mysteries
- Share a meal while hunting for clues
- Enjoy a deliciously different night out
Central New York
Turn dinner into a delicious detective adventure. Restaurants and venues in central New York can offer their own murder mystery dinners, allowing guests to enjoy your menu while becoming suspects, sharing clues and investigating an entertaining fictional crime.
- Explore murder mystery restaurants in central New York
- Enjoy delicious dining with a mysterious twist
- Discover exciting food and mystery experiences
- Dine while investigating suspicious characters
- Make your next meal wonderfully mysterious
Customer Testimonial
We made my son Emperor Palpatine and worked in three groups of five. It was a great night. I converted my dining room into the Death Star, bought dry ice for the drinks and made food from a Star Wars menu. Thank you for an amazing time. Alison Bernstein.
Our Guarantee
- Instant digital delivery
- Premium boxed game options
- Thousands of successful events
- Flexible guest numbers
- Dedicated customer support
Because the solution is not revealed beforehand, the host remains an active participant throughout the mystery.
Whether your event involves a handful of guests or a much larger crowd, a murder mystery can provide memorable entertainment.
Delivery Options
You can access your games in 2 main formats:
- Boxed: Order a premium boxed edition and have it delivered to New York within 8 to 10 days.
- Downloadable: Instantly download your game and start preparing your event in minutes.
Why choose murder mystery dinner parties in New York?
- Turn an ordinary dinner into an exciting interactive restaurant experience.
- Guests can enjoy delicious food and drinks while becoming part of the murder mystery.
- Suspicious characters, secret clues and dramatic accusations keep the dinner conversation flowing.
- Every guest receives information that can help uncover clues while they enjoy each course.
- The investigation gives everyone something intriguing to discuss between appetisers, mains and dessert.
- After dinner, guests can compare theories, reveal their suspicions and discover who solved the mystery.
How do I host a murder mystery dinner party in New York?
Make your next dinner reservation a little more sinister. A murder mystery dinner transforms a meal in New York into an interactive evening where every guest could be hiding a deadly secret. Follow these six steps to get your dining detective adventure underway.
- Pick an entertaining mystery – Select a murder mystery game designed for your guest numbers and the type of dinner you want to host.
- Choose your presenter – Host the investigation yourself, recruit a guest to run it or hire a professional murder mystery presenter.
- Choose where you will dine – Your crime scene could be a home dining room, restaurant, private function room or another suitable venue.
- Gather your guests – Invite your diners and give them the date, location and character information they need for the evening.
- Plan your dinner – Create a menu, organize drinks and add table decorations, costumes or other themed touches to enhance the experience.
- Let the investigation begin – Enjoy the food while guests reveal clues, interrogate suspects, discuss theories and uncover the identity of the murderer.
Ready to plan your murderous dinner party in New York?
Choose one of our murder mystery games below and start planning an unforgettable dinner party experience for your guests.
Christmas Capers
Soap Opera Slaughter
Wild West
View All Games
Find your perfect game!
Format:
Hosting an event in New York?
Other locations we provide dinner party games:
- Murder Mystery Dinner Party Home
- Murder Mystery Dinner Party Chicago
- Murder Mystery Dinner Party Houston
- Murder Mystery Dinner Party Los Angeles
- Murder Mystery Dinner Party Phoenix
FAQ
Do you have a custom murder mystery game?
We offer two ways to have a custom murder mystery.
Digital Custom Murder Mystery
This is where you enter your details in a database and a custom game is produced instantly to match your requirements.
Boxed Custom Murder Mystery
This is a fully custom version. We write these games from scratch and you can include any story element you wish in your mystery
How much will the whole murder mystery party cost?
You receive 2 to 3 hours of entertainment for half the price of hiring a karaoke machine.
You should factor in these costs:
- The cost of your murder mystery game.
- The cost of your murder mystery host.
- The cost of your venue.
- The cost of food and drink.
- The cost of decorations.
How long does a murder mystery dinner party typically take?
Most dinner games run between 2 to 2.5 hours, which aligns perfectly with a standard two or three-course restaurant meal service.
How does a murder mystery dinner work alongside meal service?
The game is structured to run smoothly in distinct rounds between your food courses. Guests mingle over starters, dig into clues during the main meal, and make their final accusations right before dessert, ensuring your food stays hot and the gameplay stays fast-paced.
Do we need to hire a restaurant in New York, or can we host it at home?
You can host anywhere! Our murder mystery dinners work brilliantly in private home dining rooms, rented Airbnb spaces, function rooms, or local restaurants with private dining areas.
Is this suitable for both small intimate groups and large group banquets?
Yes. We offer scalable character formats designed specifically for cozy groups of 4 to 10 guests as well as large multi-table corporate dinners with 100+ attendees.
What happens if a venue or restaurant in New York has noisy background music?
We recommend booking a private or semi-private dining space where possible. If you are in a main dining room, our host guides and printable materials ensure every guest has physical or digital clue sheets so no crucial details are missed.
Do guests need to dress up according to the theme?
Dressing up is lots of fun but we know you may not wish to be in costume in a public place. Costumes or no costumes are both great.
Can we run a self-hosted murder mystery dinner without hiring an actor?
Absolutely. Our self-hosted and DIY game kits include simple, step-by-step instructions so the host can play along or designate a guest to facilitate the rounds between courses.
What if our guest count changes at the last minute?
Our game formats feature flexible mechanics, so an unexpected drop-out or last-minute RSVP won't ruin the storyline or game balance.